The Legal Procedure for Lenders to Sell Property in Case of Loan Default in Kenya
In Kenya, many borrowers secure loans from banks and financial institutions by offering their property, particularly land, as collateral. This collateral is legally known as a “charge” on the property. Unfortunately, borrowers often default on loan repayments, leading to the sale of their properties through public auctions. A critical question arises: Do lenders follow the lawful procedure in exercising their statutory power of sale when a borrower defaults?
A key case that provides insight into this issue is Basil Criticos v. National Bank of Kenya Limited (Civil Appeal No. 80 of 2017). On April 28, 2022, the Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Basil Criticos, awarding him Kshs. 2,284,101,000 (KES 2.2 billion) for the improper sale of his property, LR No. 5865/2. The court found that the sale was unauthorized, improper, and irregular, violating the legal procedure under the Land Act, 2012.
The Law Governing Statutory Power of Sale in Kenya
The statutory power of sale is governed by the Land Act, No. 6 of 2012, which sets out clear steps a lender must follow before selling a charged property. If these steps are not followed, the sale may be deemed improper, as seen in the Criticos case. Below are the key legal requirements lenders must adhere to:
- Issuing Statutory Notices: The lender must issue a statutory notice to the borrower within one month of the default, as per Section 90 of the Land Act. This notice provides the borrower with an opportunity to rectify the default.
- Notice of Sale: Under Section 96, the lender must serve a notice of sale and wait for a period of at least 40 days before proceeding with the sale.
- Valuation of the Property: The law mandates that a certified land valuer must assess the property to ensure it is sold for no less than 75% of its market value, as stipulated in Section 97.
- Good Faith and Duty of Care: The lender must sell the property in good faith and with due diligence to avoid any exploitation of the borrower. Any surplus proceeds from the sale must be remitted to the borrower.
The Case of Basil Criticos: Lessons on Improper Property Sale
The landmark Basil Criticos case sheds light on how banks may act inappropriately when exercising their statutory power of sale. In High Court Case HCCC 132 of 2009, the National Bank of Kenya sold LR No. 5865/2 for Kshs. 55 million following a default on a Kshs. 20 million loan. However, Criticos argued that his liability as a guarantor should have been limited to the initial loan amount. He also claimed that the property, co-owned with Mama Ngina Kenyatta, was sold for much less than its market value of over Kshs. 3 billion.
While the High Court ruled in favor of the bank, dismissing Criticos’ counterclaim, the Court of Appeal later overturned this decision. The appellate judges found that the property had indeed been sold below its market value and that Criticos’ liability as a guarantor was limited. They awarded him Kshs. 2.2 billion in damages.
The Supreme Court Decision
National Bank of Kenya sought to challenge the Court of Appeal’s decision in the Supreme Court. However, the Supreme Court dismissed the application, affirming the appellate ruling that Criticos was entitled to damages for the unauthorized sale of his property.
Proper Exercise of Statutory Power of Sale
The Criticos case serves as a warning to both lenders and borrowers. Banks and other financial institutions must ensure they adhere strictly to the legal procedure before exercising the statutory power of sale. Key compliance measures include:
- Issuing the correct statutory notices within the specified timelines.
- Ensuring the property is accurately valued and sold at a fair price.
- Conducting the sale transparently and in accordance with the law.
Borrowers, on the other hand, should be vigilant and ensure they understand their rights, especially when their property is at risk of being sold.
For legal guidance on the statutory power of sale or other property-related matters, contact WKA Advocates at info@wka.co.ke or visit wakilihub.co.ke/. Our office is located at Valley View Business Park, Parklands, Nairobi.
Authors: William Karoki – Partner
Florence Mwende – Associate